Wednesday, April 04, 2007

How Tough Is Glass?

We tend to treat our glass as holy relics, being reluctant to clean and extremely careful when we do. Those of us old enough to remember when almost everyone routinely wore ties will remember cringing seeing a photographer clean his lens with the end of his tie.

Truth is, glass is pretty tough. Your windshield stands up to being scraped across with windshield wipers when it's covered in dirt , you clean your plastic glasses every day, yet years later, you are still able to see through with minimal if any impairment. OK, maybe your five year old windshield shows a bit of flare when driving into the sun, but consider the abuse, and a lot of the windshield damage is not the wipers, it's small rocks coming up and pitting the surface.

Even if you do get a major scratch on a lens, it's possible to paint the scratch black (so it doesn't cause flare) and the impact is negligible.

Modern lens coatings are pretty tough too - my glasses are multicoated and two years later the lenses look pretty darn good.

Bottom line: you have to work pretty hard to really mess up a lens. Probably the single biggest reason to fret about the surface is if you think there is a possibility of selling the lens down the road, in which case, a pristine surface does add to the value, but not to the quality of the lens. If selling a lens on isn't important, then go ahead and clean when you need to, and if you happen to not have lens tissue, go ahead with the corner of your shirt - better a clean lens and a good shot than an untouched lens and flare spots in your image (especially with wide angle lenses).

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Back in the 70s I remember Pentax was one of the first manufacturers to demonstrate how 'tough' their SMC (super multi coating) was by putting out a lit cigarette on the surface of their lens with no discolouration or effect to the coating.

Anonymous said...

I always use the end of my shirt, unless I've been sweating a lot. Those lenses are pretty tough. I do not treat my equipment with kid gloves! :-)

Anonymous said...

Multi-coated glass is very tough, but be careful with that vintage glass (especially Leica stuff with their early soft coatings).